Add CD tool comparisons

This commit is contained in:
Vladimir Moushkov
2026-01-17 12:32:01 +02:00
parent 195dff2457
commit 9b877fdae1
2 changed files with 49 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -51,6 +51,7 @@ This index provides a complete map of documentation organized by audience and to
|----------|---------|
| [product/](product/) | Product strategy and positioning hub |
| [product/competitive-landscape.md](product/competitive-landscape.md) | 15-vendor competitive analysis |
| [product/competitive-landscape.md#direct-comparisons-vs-cd-tools](product/competitive-landscape.md#direct-comparisons-vs-cd-tools) | Comparisons vs GitLab, GitHub, Jenkins, Harness |
| [product/decision-capsules.md](product/decision-capsules.md) | Decision Capsules concept |
| [product/moat-strategy-summary.md](product/moat-strategy-summary.md) | Strategic positioning |

View File

@@ -44,6 +44,54 @@ Source: internal advisories "23-Nov-2025 - Stella Ops vs Competitors" and "09-Ja
---
## Direct Comparisons vs CD Tools
These comparisons focus on where release governance, evidence export, and audit replay are required in addition to pipeline automation.
### Stella Ops Suite vs GitLab CI/CD
**Where GitLab excels:** pipeline automation, source control integration, developer workflow.
**Where Stella Ops Suite differs:**
- **Release authority** is centralized and environment-aware; not just a pipeline stage.
- **Evidence export** (Decision Capsules) is built-in and replayable months later.
- **NonK8s estates** are firstclass (Compose, VM/SSH targets, airgapped deployments).
**Bottom line:** GitLab runs pipelines; Stella Ops governs promotions with proof.
### Stella Ops Suite vs GitHub Actions
**Where GitHub excels:** PR automation, CI visibility, marketplace actions.
**Where Stella Ops Suite differs:**
- **Promotion rules** and approvals are explicit, audited, and bound to artifact digests.
- **Deterministic replay** lets auditors re-verify release decisions.
- **Offline/sovereign** operation is supported without external SaaS dependencies.
**Bottom line:** Actions automate builds; Stella Ops enforces release decisions with audit-grade evidence.
### Stella Ops Suite vs Jenkins
**Where Jenkins excels:** flexible CI, onprem extensibility.
**Where Stella Ops Suite differs:**
- **Release orchestration** includes environment graphs, approvals, and rollback semantics.
- **Evidence-grade gating** ties reachability, VEX, and policy to each promotion.
- **Exportable proof** makes compliance verification deterministic.
**Bottom line:** Jenkins executes pipelines; Stella Ops provides release governance with proof.
### Stella Ops Suite vs Harness
**Where Harness excels:** deployment automation, feature flags, multicloud rollout UX.
**Where Stella Ops Suite differs:**
- **Security evidence is a gate**, not an afterthought, and is bound to the artifact digest.
- **Decision Capsules** provide verifiable, portable audit packets.
- **NonK8s container estates** are a primary target, not a secondary path.
**Bottom line:** Harness automates delivery; Stella Ops governs releases and their evidence trail.
## Security Positioning (Original Analysis)
---